Most renters assume a lease is final. It isn't. A lease is a contract proposal — and like any contract, it's meant to be negotiated. Landlords who've been in the business know this. You should too.
What You Can Negotiate (And What You Can't)
Almost any non-statutory clause is negotiable. Here's a useful framework:
- •✅ Security deposit amount or structure
- •✅ Early termination penalty
- •✅ Lease length (month-to-month vs. annual)
- •✅ Pet deposit and monthly pet rent
- •✅ Specific repair commitments (e.g., "landlord will replace dishwasher before move-in")
- •✅ Removal of illegal or one-sided clauses
- •❌ Legally required terms (eviction procedures, required notices)
- •❌ Rent control-set maximum rent increases
The Right Approach: Written, Professional, Specific
Always negotiate in writing. Email is best. It creates a paper trail and gives the landlord time to think without feeling put on the spot.
Script 1: Requesting Removal of an Illegal Clause
Hi [Landlord Name], Thank you for sending the lease. I've had a chance to review it and I'm very interested in the unit. I noticed Section [X] states "[quote the clause]." I believe this clause may conflict with [State] [Statute Name], which [briefly explain]. I'd like to request that this clause be removed or modified before I sign. I'm happy to proceed and move quickly once this is addressed. Please let me know your thoughts. Best, [Your Name]
Script 2: Negotiating a Junk Fee
Hi [Landlord Name], I've reviewed the lease and noticed a $[amount] [fee name] in addition to the security deposit. I'd like to understand what this fee covers — and I'd like to request it be removed or applied toward the deposit, since [State] law generally only permits [permitted fees]. I'm enthusiastic about the unit and want to move forward quickly. Happy to discuss. Best, [Your Name]
Script 3: Negotiating Early Termination Terms
Hi [Landlord Name], The lease currently specifies an early termination penalty of [X months' rent]. Given that this is significantly above what's typical in the market, I'd like to propose reducing this to [1 month's rent] with [30-60] days advance notice. I plan to stay for the full lease term, but I want to ensure there's a fair exit clause given life's unpredictability. Happy to discuss. Best, [Your Name]
What If the Landlord Says No?
If a landlord refuses to remove a clause that's clearly illegal, that tells you something important. At minimum, document it. If you still want the unit, know that an illegal clause is unenforceable regardless — but you may have to fight it later. Consider consulting a local tenant rights organization before signing.
Check Your Own Lease Now
Everything in this guide applies to leases in general — but your lease may have specific clauses that need their own review. Upload it free.
Analyze My Lease — Free